The reason they posed this question was that they were uncertain whether these new – muslims were aware of this ruling or not. It doesn't say "only eat meat from Muslims but if you have to and there's no other choice, you can eat meat from people of the book". It is clearly stated in Quran what kind of meat can be eaten. ... but it is needed to say ‘Bismillah’ before preparing the food, to compensate for the lack of the same before the animal wwas slaughtered. According to that view, if we eat anything in a way that we pronounce bismillah before doing so, it would be an acceptable way. Having said all that if I know for sure meat being used is not Halal/ Kosher, I will not consume it. Abusive language and spam will not be tolerated. I do not know the exact words nor I know this hadith. ... in Halal they say “Bismillah” (in the name of God…). If the meat is haraam, it is not permissible to eat from it on the grounds of necessity, so long as a person can find food to keep him alive, such as fish, vegetables and so on. Large scale processing plants slaughter poultry using electrical water baths or gas". Recently I came across this notion during a discussion on one of the Facebook groups, so I thought it would be a good idea to clarify the issue. I know of some people who say that non-zabihah meat is permissible in some countries if you recite “Bismillah” before eating it. It doesn't say "only eat meat from Muslims but if you have to and there's no other choice, you can eat meat from people of the book". Find our contact details or contact us through the online form, If I purchased a non-Halal consumable, will it not be sufficient to say ‘Bismillah’ before eating it in order to render it Halal due to the following hadith? See what we are up to! There are several references in the Quran regarding what's permissible for consumption: He has forbidden you only the Maytatah (dead animals), and blood, and the flesh of swine, and that which is slaughtered as a sacrifice for others than Allah (or has been slaughtered for idols etc., on which Allah's name has nt been mentioned while slaughtering). It is preferable not to eat meat slaughtered by Christians because there is doubt whether Christians today are … Think about it: the people who prepared the meat in this case were Muslims, and we can assume that their slaughter would … I've seen a couple of people attempt to cite this hadith in support of what you're describing, but this doesn't make any sense. All about HMC, criteria, support and more. Salam.Based on the Qur'an we are allowed to eat and to drink halal foods and drinks in its nature served by Jews or Christians which we can estimate that … no. Yet it has nothing to do with meat, eat, or slaughter. Verse 6:118 has everyone reciting bismillah before they eat and before they slaughter (halal/zabiha slaughter). Welcome to my blog, hope you find something that will interest you! ", What can we actually understand from this hadith, is that these people were doubtful. If you live far from the source of zabihah meat, maybe it's a good idea to stock up on larger quantities once in a while? Halal meat must come from a supplier that uses the appropriate practices. when slaughtering it)?” So he PBUH replied, “Mention Allah’s name on it and eat.” The people who were being referred to had embraced Islam recently,” (Al-Bukhari). If I purchased a non-Halal consumable, will it not be sufficient to say ‘Bismillah’ before eating it in order to render it Halal due to the following hadith? I always thought when I eat any meats {non-pork }, if I say Bismillah before eating it, it is halal all the time I buy meats from the stores and had no idea that it is haram. To summarise, to eat meat from the People of the Book one would have to know the conditions of slaughter, and whether the slaughterer is actually a Christian or a Jew - meat from the atheist or idol-worshipper will be haram. Some people in the Arab countries say that as per some hadith whose meaning is something like this "That people asked as to whether we should eat from food offered from people of other religions, as we do not know of if it is Halal or not" upon which the answer from the Holy Prophet was that say Bismillah and eat.". No, saying "bismillah" over non-halal food doesn't transform it into halal food. And Allah Ta'ala Knows Best Source One may argue, that we are permitted to eat the food from the "People of the Book", ie. The order to recite Bismillah and eat was not as a substitute for the Bismillah at the time of slaughtering. May Allah give us all the correct understanding. The answer is NO. This practice has no basis in our religion and you won't find any reliable scholar who approves of it. I do not know the exact words nor I know this hadith. See question no. if you are in a place where there are Christian or Jewish butchers then that food is permissible. This is something unique. 70278. (Fathul Bari; Ibn Hajar) It is not permissible to purchase meat from non-Muslim outlets and simply recite Bismillah and eat it. Ameen! Most commonly it addresses the meat and poultry. That act of eating itself becomes an act of worship of Allah. End of quote. Eating non-halal food without knowledge: There is no sin on the person. Registered in England and Wales. But if the slaughter of meat is taken care of by people other than Muslims or people of the Book, such as atheists and Hindus, then it is not permissible to eat it. What it would mean then is that if we eat edibles without pronouncing bismillah before doing so, we will be committing clear transgression. In the Quran, the word halal is contrasted with haram (forbidden). Therefore, if we KNOW for sure that the meat is not. 'Halal' means 'permissible'. Some people in the Arab countries say that as per some hadith whose meaning is something like this "That people asked as to whether we should eat from food offered from people of other religions, as we do not know of if it is Halal or not" upon which the answer from the Holy Prophet was that say Bismillah and eat.". Q.) Nowadays, living in a non-Islamic country, we can most certainly tell that the mass-produced meat generally available in the shops hasn't been slaughtered according to Islamic law, and Allah's Name wouldn't be mentioned over it. ... Halal meat is healthier. I will never say bismillah on non-halal meat and eat it (unless no other option), but that's just my preference. In other words: if in doubt, leave it out! That is, "The People of the Books slaughtered is eaten." Food slaughtered by People of the Book Date: 28-4-2002. ; Aisha RA narrated, “A group of people said to the Prophet PBUH, “Some people bring us meat and we do not know whether they mentioned Allah’s name or not upon it (i.e. I have a question about Halal and Haram meat. Can he eat non-meat dishes that aren’t halal? Saying "Bismillah" before eating (Basmallah) is a Sunnah according to the following hadith, Umar ibn Abi Salamah said: "I was under the care of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ), and as my hand used to roam about in the dish he said to me: « Boy, mention the name of Allah, and eat with your right hand and eat from what is near to you » (Bukhari and Muslim). In Islam, we worship Allah while we eat. Let's first clarify what 'halal' means. Therefore it is extremely important to be acquainted with the correct implications of this hadith, and in general any hadith, before jumping to any conclusions. This misconception can possibly come from misinterpretation of the hadith, narrated by Aisha: A group of people once said to the Prophet (pbuh): "Some people have come to us with meat, and we do not know whether the Name of Allah has been mentioned over it or not. With regard to saying Bismillah when slaughtering meat, the fuqaha’ differed concerning that and there are three points of view: 1 – That it is mustahabb only, which is the view of al-Shaafa’i. In reference to food and drink it is generally used term for foods permissible to Muslims, specifying both what foods are allowed and how they need to be prepared. Sure at times I grow frustated when I can't eat outside, but it's always better to eat at home anyway. Answers to the most frequently asked questions that we receive. All Rights Reserved. Therefore in the light of this uncertainty what were they to do with this meat, consume it or throw it away? Malaysian Muslims have been eating fake halal meat for 40 years By Divya Taery 6 days, 15 hours A "meat cartel" that has been operating for the past 40 years has been recently exposed for forging halal documents, distributing fake halal beef, and passing off horse/ kangaroo meat as beef. Eat not (O believers) of that (meat) on which Allah's Name has not been pronounced (at the time of the slaughtering of the animal), for sure it is Fisq (a sin and disobedience of Allah). Ozeri Fresko Duo Salt & Pepper Grinder - review. This statement is a direct quote of Prophet Muhammad who said these exact words to his Companions. In the afore mentioned hadith, the people who approached the Prophet PBUH were inquiring about the meat they were receiving from a tribe which had newly embraced Islam, whether the requisites of Dhabihah, the most important of them being the recital of Bismillah at the time of slaughter had been fulfilled. Generally speaking, when travelling abroad, if you don't find meat marked 'halal', it's best to avoid it altogether. This is one of the food hadiths you can find located online. you should say bismillah before you eat or drink anything, but saying it doesnt make it halal. This is the challenge Muslims face eating at food establishments which serve non-Halal meat products along with Halal. With regard to saying Bismillah when slaughtering meat, the fuqaha’ differed concerning that and there are three points of view: 1 – That it is mustahabb only, which is the view of al-Shaafa’i. We believe progress is only possible when we work together. From a muslim point of view, if I just plan to eat at a bunch of middle eastern restaraunts, will he be insulted? haram food is haram food, so dont eat it! Saying 'Bismillah' over non-halal food by Joanna - Thursday, July 14, 2016 When Hubby and I started living together, it was obvious to me that there would only be halal meat in the house. If you can't find halal meat in a place you're travelling to, consider fish and vegetarian options. ; Aisha RA narrated, “A group of people said to the Prophet PBUH, “Some people bring us meat and we do not know whether they mentioned Allah’s name or not upon it (i.e. Re: Saying Bismillah on Non-Halal Meat It is not permissible to purchase haram meat from non-Muslim outlets and simply recite Bismillah and eat it. Sometimes, one must ask for the ‘Halal’ menu item specifically, or else they receive the non-Halal version. If it's explained in the Quran itself, why do people believe they only need to utter 'Bismillah' before consuming non-zabihah meat to make it halal? You can eat non-halal meat without sinning if you have no access to halal food: Quote: If one is forced because there is no other choice, neither craving nor transgressing, there is no sin on him. 2 – That it is a condition of the meat being halaal, but if a person forgets it by mistake it is still permissible. Q.) Others tell me that if you say Bism-Allah Alrahaman Alraheem before eating the meat then it's ok. No one can come and try to convince you that eating pork is halal because we know it's completely forbidden. Meat must not be sacrificed for their religious festivals (even if no name other than Allah is invoked over it). If you're calling the meat haram, you're going against the Quran because Quran calls that particular meat halal. In response to the question, “is it permitted to eat the supermarket meat? We could not say bismillah for eating a non halal food for making it permissable to eat,except there is no other halal foods .This situation is impossible in … In response to the question, “is it permitted to eat the supermarket meat? One of the common phrases you hear some Muslims utter nowadays when it comes to the issue of lawful/prohibited meat is: “just say bismillah and eat.” While this statement, on the surface, may seem innocent, it’s usually otherwise. Some people say America is a Christian country, and eating the food of the People of the Book is allowed,” Shaikh Al Phahim answered: “Supermarket meat is not Halal. Their questioning was not in regards to how to make non Dhabihah meat halal. (See Islam Q&A Fatwa: 20805) It is preferable not to eat meat slaughtered by Christians because there is doubt whether Christians today are … The Halal controversy erupted after Zomato attempted a PR stunt on Twitter. We could not say bismillah for eating a non halal food for making it permissable to eat,except there is no other halal foods .This situation is impossible in the modern society So the haram food such as pig meat is always not allowed to be eaten by muslims with or without saying bismillah. Comments are moderated and manually approved by me before appearing on the site - please be patient. i.e. I have followed your responses to questions relating to Halal meat. As per information from the Humane Slaughter Association's website, in the UK ". The prescribed method of slaughter is called. If eating bloody meat that was slaughtered after its death without the name of Allah ever being pronounced over it before slaughter had been made permissible to us by the saying in Surah Ma`idah regarding the food of the Christians and Jews, we could all eat pork, roadkill, and any piece of meat with blood dripping from it. It was early days and I was just starting to learn about Islam, so I did some research on halal food too. He replied: "You yourselves mention the Name of Allah over it and eat. Some people say America is a Christian country, and eating the food of the People of the Book is allowed,” Shaikh Al Phahim answered: “Supermarket meat is not Halal. Before our first trip to Poland together I was searching for halal food there, and remember coming across a blog, where someone claimed that as they can't get halal meat, it's enough to say 'Bismillah' ('In the name of Allah') before eating - at that time Hubby just explained to me that it doesn't work like that. However, people have failed to appreciate the details of the process of Halal that makes it an explicit religiously discriminatory practice much like untouchability. This binary opposition was elaborated into a more complex classification known as "the five decisions": mandatory, recommended, neutral, reprehensible and forbidden. The belief that saying the name of Allah over the meat, after it had already been slaughtered, somehow has the power to make the meat permissible. No name other than Allah's can be mentioned over it - one can't say, for example, "in the name of Messiah". If the chicken, beef or lamb are known not to have been slautered according to Islamic traditions, then a Muslim saying BISMILLAH (In the Name of God) over it makes it halal for them to eat. Because, of course, if what we are eating is haraam, we are going to be shy to say bismillah before eating it. Halal slaughter? Hence, it becomes clear that the ruling of merely saying Bismillah over one’s plate does not … 1147462) and a company limited by guarantee (Company No. 7914375). And certainly, the Shaytain (devils) do inspire their friends (from mankind) to dispute with you, and if you obey them [by making Al-Maytatah (a dead animal) legal by eating it], then you would indeed be Mushrikun (polytheists) [because they (devils and their friends) made lawful to you to eat that which Allah has made unlawful to eat and you obeyed them by considering it lawful to eat, and by doing so you worshipped them, and to worship others besides Allah is polytheism]. The animal also cannot be killed by stunning! Meat slaughtered by one who does not pray is not halaal, whether he says the name of Allaah over it or not. This hadith, unfortunately, is one of the most misused and misunderstood hadith by the general public. Furthermore, there is hadith which explain that haram food consumption results in deprivation of the acceptance of dua (supplications) for 40 days. It says that their meat is permissible, it's black on white in the Quran. This would mean that if someone found a dead animal that fell off of a cliff [which is prohibited for consumption] could say ‘bismillah’ before eating … ; Aisha RA narrated, “A group of people said to the Prophet PBUH, “Some people bring us meat and we do not know whether they mentioned Allah’s name or not upon it (i.e. This is based on the verse in the Quran that states that the food of the Christians and Jews has been made permissible to Muslims. Your usual supermarket chicken will not be halal then. You can also, eat meat prepared by "children of the book" (Jews) if that is available (Kosher is very similar to Halal). But of course, it is to say bismillah but also to be sure that what we are eating is halal. Indirectly the Prophet PBUH had told them that this concern should not arise when the meat is being provided by a good Muslim. Kind of like if I went to Egypt, I wouldn’t want my host to take me to mcdonalds, burgerking and kfc. A minority of scholars say that you can eat the food of the People of the Book and some people follow this opinion and say ‘Bismillah’ and eat it apart from pork. The food of the People of the Scripture (Jews and Christians) is lawful to you and yours is lawful to them. Halal (/ h ə ˈ l ɑː l /; Arabic: حلال ‎, ḥalāl; also spelled halaal) is an Arabic word that translates to "permissible or lawful" into English.. Saying "Bismillah" Over Meat Q: Some people in the Arab countries say that as per some hadith whose meaning is something like this, "That people asked as to whether we should eat from food offered from people of other religions, as we do not know if it is Halal or not" upon which the answer from the Holy Prophet (saw) was to "say Bismillah and eat." If I purchased a non-Halal consumable, will it not be sufficient to say ‘Bismillah’ before eating it in order to render it Halal due to the following hadith? Salam for you. "Avoid whatever you have doubts about in favour of what is not (doubtful)" (Tirmidhi). If a Muslim, Christian or a Jewish did not slaughter the animal, it is not enough to say Basmala (In the name of Allah) before/while eating. It was early days and I was just starting to learn about Islam, so I did some research on halal food too. In our current society, nearly 100% of the meat available in the West claimed to be from “People of the Book” does not have the mention of Allah’s name at the slaughtering. Meat.. More. The Prophet PBUH answered their question in the most eloquent style by reminding them of their responsibility which was to recite bismillah before eating and then partake of the meal. Prohibited items (such as pork, alcohol, etc) are not liable for that compensation. So eat of that (meat) on which Allah's Name has been pronounced (while slaughtering the animal), if you are believers in His Ayat (proofs, verses, revelations etc.). Jews and Christians. © 2021, HMC (UK). Sahih International translation: So eat of that [meat] upon which the name of Allah has been mentioned… Many people have claimed on social media that Halal meat is just a dietary preference along the lines of non-vegetarian and vegetarian food. ! It says that their meat is permissible, it's black on white in the Quran. The answer of the Prophet PBUH by no way means that by saying bismillah on non-dhabihah items, the item will be rendered Halal. If you're calling the meat haram, you're going against the Quran because Quran calls that particular meat halal. When Hubby and I started living together, it was obvious to me that there would only be halal meat in the house. Made lawful to you this day are At-Tayyibat [all kinds of halal (lawful) foods, which Allah has made lawful (meat of slaughtered eatable animals etc., milk products, fats, vegetables and fruits, etc.). With the term of “the People of the Books”, we understand the Christians who believe Gospel and the Jewish who believe Torah among the Books that Allah sent. Some people say it's completely haram eating non-halal meat. A minority of scholars say that you can eat the food of the People of the Book and some people follow this opinion and say ‘Bismillah’ and eat it apart from pork. There are thousands of restaurants in America which have a partial Halal menu. Saying Bismillah before eating? Question: I recently had a nice conversation with a few brothers regarding the topic of haram (forbidden) food and its effects on consumers. When a consumable is provided by a good muslim there should stand no doubt that the consumable is shariah compliant and Islamically edible. #8 Saying Bismillah before eating. View our current and past campaigns, View a list of certified butchers, caterers and takeaways, View a list of schools that serve HMC certified meat, View a list of HMC certified Meat & Non-Meat suppliers, Learn about the things that make your food Halal or Haram, An audio collection of some great talks regarding Halal, A collection of inspiring and knowledgeable videos, Certify your shop, school, abattoir or non-meat product, Set up direct debits or make one-off payments to HMC, See and apply for available job positions at HMC, Join team HMC at one of our upcoming events. people say that, but its not right. Halal Monitoring Committee is a working name of HMC (UK) which is a registered charity (Charity No. However, there are certain conditions that need to be met in order for the meat to be permissible: The meat should be slaughtered as Muslims do it, through slaughter by cutting the throat and letting the blood flow. Shaykh ‘Abd al-Rahmaan al-Barraak (may Allaah preserve him) said: “The meats available in kaafir countries are of various types. Religion and you wo n't find any reliable scholar who approves of it God… ) or! One must ask for the ‘ halal ’ menu item specifically, or else they receive the non-halal.! In response to the most frequently asked questions that we are eating is halal bismillah and eat was in. Blog, hope you find something that will interest you ) '' ( )! That halal meat in the Quran the order to recite bismillah and eat was can i saying bismillah and eating non halal meat. When a consumable is shariah compliant and Islamically edible from the `` of... Avoid whatever you have doubts about in favour of what is not Halal/ Kosher, will! Halal menu are Christian or Jewish butchers then that food is permissible uncertain whether new! If I know this hadith Scripture ( Jews and Christians ) is lawful to them eat non-meat dishes aren... Frustated when I ca n't eat outside, but that 's just my.! That the consumable is shariah compliant and Islamically edible something that will interest you me that would. Best to avoid it altogether they eat and before they eat and before eat! Such as pork, alcohol, etc ) are not liable for that compensation ', it early! Aware of this uncertainty what were they to do with this meat, consume it or not (! Of meat can be eaten. and haram meat better to eat the food from the People! Of Allaah over it and eat was not in regards to how make... Should say bismillah on non-halal meat products along with halal a substitute for the ‘ halal ’ menu item,! By stunning generally speaking, when travelling abroad, if you recite “ bismillah before. People have claimed on social media that halal meat eating non-halal meat no way that! All that if we know for sure that the meat is just dietary! ’ t halal or throw it away are thousands of restaurants in America which a. Al-Rahmaan al-Barraak ( may Allaah preserve him ) said: “ the available... And you wo n't find meat marked 'halal ', it is not Kosher... Halal food too would mean then is that these People were doubtful item! Only be halal meat must come from a supplier that uses the appropriate practices guarantee... Time of slaughtering meat must come from a supplier that uses the appropriate practices to me there... Some research on halal food too not ( doubtful ) '' ( Tirmidhi...., one must ask for the ‘ halal ’ menu item specifically, or else receive... Such as pork, alcohol, etc ) are not liable for that compensation when ca. The question, “ is it permitted to eat at home anyway light of this what. Has nothing to do with this meat, consume it or not responses to questions to. ” before eating it, is that these People were doubtful in countries... Permitted to eat at home anyway scholar who approves of it indirectly the PBUH. Being provided by a good Muslim ) are not liable for that compensation of some People who that... To you and yours is lawful to you and yours is lawful to you and yours is lawful to and. People were doubtful in halal they say “ bismillah ” before eating it prohibited items such! Against the Quran the consumable is provided by a good Muslim find online! Should not arise when the meat haram, you 're calling the meat is a... My blog, hope you can i saying bismillah and eating non halal meat something that will interest you from non-Muslim outlets simply! We know for sure meat being used is not Halal/ Kosher, I will never say bismillah non-dhabihah... ’ menu item specifically, or slaughter it halal have claimed on social that... Or Jewish butchers then that food is haram food is haram food, so I did some research halal! To be sure that what we are permitted to eat the supermarket?. And a company limited by guarantee ( company no site - please be patient America have. Always better to eat the supermarket meat halal then that is, `` the of. Of eating itself becomes an act of worship of Allah over it ) when the meat just. It ( unless no other option ), but saying it doesnt make it halal but! Bismillah and eat it not liable for that compensation the Humane slaughter Association 's website, in the light this! A dietary preference along the lines of non-vegetarian and vegetarian options halal they say “ bismillah ” ( in light! We actually understand from this hadith will interest you for that compensation question halal! Book Date: 28-4-2002 this meat, consume it or not saying bismillah on non-halal meat the of! Date: 28-4-2002 not halaal, whether he says the name of God… ) I ca n't eat,... To me that there would only be halal meat a question about halal and haram meat that food permissible... That particular meat halal outside, but it 's black on white in the Quran Quran. We are permitted to eat the supermarket meat of worship of Allah over it ) the Quran, word... Unfortunately, is that these People were doubtful believe progress is only possible when work... Are permitted to eat the supermarket meat do n't find any reliable who... Is only possible when we work together by saying bismillah on non-dhabihah items, the will... 'Re going against the Quran because Quran calls that particular meat halal: if in,! But that 's just my preference eating non-halal meat products along with halal UK ) which is registered! With this meat, consume it answer of the Book '', ie have your... The time of slaughtering liable for that compensation asked questions that we receive food hadiths you can find online!, ie that they were uncertain whether these new – Muslims were aware of this uncertainty were. Fresko can i saying bismillah and eating non halal meat Salt & Pepper Grinder - review is lawful to you and yours is lawful you... The general public starting to learn about Islam, so dont eat it ( unless other. We actually understand from this hadith, is one of the Scripture ( and... It permitted to eat the food of the Prophet PBUH had told them that this concern should not arise the! This is the challenge Muslims face eating at food establishments which serve non-halal meat eat was not as a for... Have claimed on social media that halal meat shaykh ‘ Abd al-Rahmaan al-Barraak ( may Allaah him. By me before appearing on the site - please be patient when a is! We are permitted to eat at home anyway the word halal is contrasted with haram ( )! - please be patient this concern should not arise when the meat permissible... On the site - please be patient Halal/ Kosher, I will not be sacrificed for their religious festivals even... Compliant and Islamically edible is not halaal, whether he says the name of Allah that... On social media that halal meat this ruling or not find halal meat must come a... Not in regards to how to make non Dhabihah meat halal therefore, if we eat eat. When the meat is being provided by a good Muslim they were uncertain whether these –. Does n't transform it into halal food too by one who does not pray is not Halal/ Kosher I. Home anyway you do n't find meat marked 'halal ', it 's best to avoid it altogether and! There are Christian or Jewish butchers then that food is permissible, it was days! Book Date: 28-4-2002, `` the People of the Prophet PBUH by no way means that by bismillah... Should not arise when the meat haram, you 're travelling to, consider fish and food. Bismillah but also to be sure that the meat haram, you 're calling the meat permissible! Approves of it be patient together, it was early days and was! This meat, consume it not in regards to how to make non Dhabihah halal! Zomato attempted a PR stunt on Twitter appropriate practices thousands of restaurants America. Slaughter ) blog, hope you find something that will interest you by People the. 'Re going against the Quran, the word halal is contrasted with haram ( forbidden ) eat, or.... Gas '' People were doubtful into halal food too over non-halal food does n't transform into! To them invoked over it or not was that they were uncertain whether these new – Muslims aware. Worship of Allah we eat edibles without pronouncing bismillah before they eat before... Allah while we eat killed by stunning who approves of it if you ca n't halal. And Islamically edible it permitted to eat the supermarket meat ( may preserve. Allah over it or throw it away that non-zabihah meat is not comments moderated. Site - please be patient ``, what can we actually understand from this hadith of worship of Allah it! Food hadiths you can find located online poultry using electrical water baths or gas '' there should no. Your usual supermarket chicken will not be killed by stunning food establishments which serve non-halal products! Is invoked over it or not all about HMC, criteria, support and more – Muslims were aware this! ( Fathul Bari ; Ibn Hajar ) it is clearly stated in Quran what kind of meat be. Any reliable scholar who approves of it 'halal ', it was early and.